Fish Frydays in Dane County

Posted by Kelly Holck on Wednesday, January 16th, 2019 at 2:41pm.

If you're a Wisconsin native (or have lived here long enough), then you know that attending a Fish Fry on a Friday night is a natural part of life. 

If you've only been in Wisconsin for a short time or just so happened to take an accidental detour to our beautiful country, you probably have no idea what I'm talking about.

Whichever person you are, I can almost guarantee you that it will benefit your happiness and stomach to continue reading.

A fish fry is an event where many different types of fish are thrown into some batter and deep fried, then served on a plate with coleslaw, potato pancakes, and/or other delectable, comfort food sides. If you're someone who's looking out for his/her health, your fish fry may be baked, sans breading. Either way, your tastebuds will never forgive you if "fish fry" isn't in your Friday vocabulary.

If you're picking up what I'm putting down, smelling what I'm stepping in, catching what I'm throwing, cashing what I'm checking...but you're not sure where to go, don't fret! I've compiled a list below, where you'll find our favorite Friday night spots to catch a fish fry in Dane County, WI.

FYI: if you'd like more information on the establishments, click the establishment name and you'll be directed to their website.

 

Team Favorites

I asked the team which fish fry is their favorite. Though we each have a few we love, I was able to shorten the list to the absolute favorite, Dane County fish fry for each of us. If you're out on a Friday night and happen to venture into one of these establishments, you'll understand why they made the cut.

 

Shawn's Pick :: The Hilltop 

Why: Delicious food, great atmosphere, and you can make reservations *as long as you have a party of 6 or larger, so bring your friends!
When: Open 4PM-10PM on Frydays
Where: 4173 Co Hwy P, Cross Plains, WI 53528
Contact: 608.798.2893
What:

4.5/5 stars on Google
3.5/5 stars on Yelp
4.6/5 stars on Facebook

 

Jill's Pick :: Oakcrest Tavern

Why: In the words of Jill Sloan, "Because it's legendary!" Plus, the cod is cooked just right, the curds are delicious, and they offer fish fry Wednesday nights as well!
When: Open 11AM-12Am on Wednesdays, 11AM-1AM on Frydays, Fish Fry served 5PM-10PM
Where: 5371 Old Middleton Rd, Madison, WI
Contact: 608.233.1243
What:

4.5/5 stars on Google
4/5 stars on Yelp
4.7/5 stars on Facebook

 

Christian's Pick :: St. Luke's Catholic Church

Why: The food is SUPER good, it's All You Can Eat, it's volunteer-based, there's a sense of community, and the people are SO nice.
When: Serving 5PM-8PM on **select** Frydays, listed below

Where: 1240 Nachreiner Ave, Plain, WI 53577
Contact: 608.546.2482
What: Though I couldn't find a specific menu online, based on their volunteer signup page they have: AYCE fish, veggies, potatoes, salad, dessert bars, coffee, and milk. This is all for $13.00/adult, $6.00/children 6-12, and $1.00/children 5 years and under! Also, in case you're looking to volunteer, they still have slots open for the February 1st fish fry! Not only will you (most likely) get to enjoy a fantastic fish fry, but you'll be doing your part for the community. Everyone is welcome to join!
4.8/5 stars on Facebook

 

Kelly's Pick :: Toby's Supper Club

Why: You get a RIDICULOUS amount of food, the fish is to die for (too bad they had to...), and it's one of the last real, traditional Supper Clubs. Don't forget to order an Old Fashioned while you're there; they do not disappoint! They don't take reservations so show up plenty ahead of time because it's no secret that they know what they're doing.
When: Open Frydays 5PM-10:30PM
Where: 3717 S Dutch Mill Rd, Madison, WI 53718
Contact: 608.222.6913
What: **All dinners come with salad, potato, relish, and roll**

4.5/5 stars on Google
4/5 stars on Yelp
4.6/5 stars on Facebook

 


Other Dane County Fryday Favorites

I did a little of my own online research/quality control/taste testing and came up with a short list of crowd favorites, below. Though you can easily do your own Google research, I thought it might be nice for you to have all of the details in one place.

 

Buck & Honey's

Why: Great atmosphere, great service, original menu, there's a cheesecake of the day, and you can make reservations!
When: Open 11AM-Close, Fish Fry served 4PM-10PM
Where: 804 Liberty Blvd, Sun Prairie, WI 53590
Contact: 608.837.3131
What:

4.3/5 stars on Google
3.5/5 stars on Yelp
4.5/5 stars on Facebook
5/5 stars in my heart

 

Avenue Club and The Bubble Up Bar

Why: The people love it: voted "Madison's Best Fish Fry" many times and also has their fish fry featured in the "Best of Madison" section in Madison Magazine. Don't feel like waiting for Friday to get your fish fry? No problem. Avenue Club and The Bubble Up Bar serves their fish fry for dinner 7 days a week and for lunch Monday-Friday. Plus, check out this cool deal you can grab online.



When: Open Frydays 11AM-11PM, though the kitchen closes at 10PM
Where: 1128 E Washington Ave, Madison, WI 53703
Contact: 608.257.6877
What:

4.1/5 stars on Google
3.5/5 stars on Yelp
4.3/5 stars on Facebook

 

Green Acres

Why: People RAVE about the fish, it's a classic Wisconsin Supper Club, and there's a salad bar. If you already have your regular Friday night establishment, you can always grab fish fry here on Tuesday nights as well! Reservations are welcome on Tuesdays but not accepted on Fridays so show up early.
When:
Open 4:30-10PM on Frydays
Where:
7470 WI-78 Trunk, Sauk City, WI 53583
Contact:
608.643.2305
What:

4.4/5 stars on Google
4/5 stars on Yelp
4.7/5 stars on Facebook

 

Dahmen's at Hawks

Why: Their Walleye is amazing, the fish fry is served all day on Fridays, their menu is super quirky, and if you need an excuse to be on that side of town, it's located inside the Hawks Landing Golf Clubhouse; go play 18 holes and then grab a bite to eat. It's definitely worth checking out!
When:
11AM-12AM
Where:
88 Hawks Landing Circle, Verona, WI 53593
Contact:
608.848.5751 
What:

4.4/5 stars on Google
4/5 stars on Yelp
4.9/5 on Facebook

 

If you know me personally, you know I could go on and on when it comes to food (especially fish fry). However, considering I've spent most of my day carving out my plans for the next year's worth of Fridays AKA writing this blog post, I think I'll cut myself off here. There are a ton of other great establishments in Madison and Dane County that offer fish fry on Fridays. Check out some of the places I've listed above, or go on your own adventure and find a hidden gem that you'll later share with me. Either way, I doubt you'll be disappointed. 

 

And, if you want to be a regular Fish Fry Goer but don't own a house in Dane County, give us a call! We're happy to help you fulfill your Fish Fry dreams while also fulfilling your homeowner dreams.

608.729.7351 or DaneCountyMarket@gmail.com

Leave a Comment

Format example: you@domain.com
Format example: yourwebsitename.com

Sign up for email updates